Skip to main content
Start My Appraisal

Your Guide to the Roof Insurance Claim Process

What Is Appraisal?

Answering Homeowner FAQs and More

Start Your Claim Today
How Apr Wroks

How Appraisals Work

Appraisal is a formal process to resolve disputes about the value of damages between you and your insurance company. If you can’t agree on the cost to repair the damage—even after honest attempts to reach a resolution—either party can initiate the appraisal process in writing.

Here’s how it works: both you and the insurance company choose a qualified, impartial appraiser. These professionals evaluate the claim and estimate what it will take to restore the property. If the two appraisers can’t agree, they’ll bring in a neutral umpire to make the final decision.

The appraisal process is designed to take the stress out of resolving disputes. It’s about cutting through the back-and-forth and getting to a fair solution so you can move forward with restoring your home or commercial property. 
That’s where ClaimRef comes in—we’re the referees for your property, ensuring a smooth, fair, and efficient process for everyone involved.

Situations That Call for an Appraisal

There are a wide variety of reasons disputes arise during the insurance claims process, from disagreements over repair costs to the extent of damages. Appraisals provide a fair, efficient way to resolve these conflicts when other efforts fall short. Here are some of the most common situations where an appraisal can help.
Underpaid Claims

Sometimes, the settlement your insurance company offers isn’t enough to cover the actual cost of roof repairs.

For example, you might receive a payout for standard materials when your roof requires premium materials like slate or specialized commercial roofing systems.

In these cases, an appraisal helps ensure the settlement accurately reflects the true cost of restoring your property.

Start My Claim
Disputed Scope of Damage

Disagreements often arise over the extent of damage caused by storms or other events.

Your insurer might only acknowledge visible roof damage while ignoring issues like hidden water intrusion or structural harm.

Appraisals bring in impartial experts to evaluate the full scope of damage and provide a fair assessment.

Start My Claim
Denied Claims

Insurance companies may deny roof claims, arguing that damages were pre-existing or not covered under your policy.

For instance, storm damage might be blamed on wear and tear to avoid payment.

An appraisal provides an independent review, giving you a chance to challenge an unfair denial.

Start My Claim
Slow Negotiations

Prolonged back-and-forth negotiations with your insurance company can delay much-needed repairs. This is especially frustrating when timelines for rebuilding or reopening a business are critical.

Appraisals can speed up the process by cutting through delays and focusing on resolution.

Start My Claim
Commercial Property Complexities

For large or multi-structure properties, disputes over repair costs or valuation can quickly escalate.

A commercial property owner might face conflicting assessments for high-cost repair or business interruption claims.

Appraisals provide an objective third-party evaluation to resolve these more complex disputes efficiently.

Start My Claim
Disagreements Over Replacement vs. Repair

Insurers may push for patchwork repairs when a full replacement is necessary to ensure safety and longevity.

For example, they might approve replacing a few shingles when the entire roof needs replacing due to damage.

An appraisal ensures the repair plan aligns with what’s truly needed for your property.

Start My Claim

Where ClaimRef Steps in 

When things get challenging with your insurance claim, we’re here to make it easier. Our team brings the expertise and support you need to navigate disputes and achieve a fair resolution. We’re committed to helping you move forward with confidence.
Simplifying the Process
Accordion Icon
Dealing with insurance claims can be frustrating and time-consuming, but we’re here to make it easier. Our team handles the details, communicates with the insurance company, and guides you through every step. With ClaimRef, you can rest assured that the process will be clear, straightforward, and stress-free.
Fair and Accurate Assessments
Accordion Icon
Our impartial appraisers provide a detailed, unbiased evaluation of your property’s damage. This ensures that every aspect of your claim is properly accounted for, from visible issues to hidden damages. With ClaimRef, you can trust that your settlement reflects the true cost of repairs.
Faster Resolutions
Accordion Icon
We streamline the appraisal process to help you avoid drawn-out negotiations and delays. By cutting through the back-and-forth with insurance companies, we keep your claim moving forward. This means you can focus on restoring your property without unnecessary setbacks.
Residential and Commercial Expertise
Accordion Icon
We bring specialized knowledge to every claim, whether it’s a home or a commercial building. Our appraisers have experience with a wide range of property types and understand the unique challenges they present. With Claims Ref, your claim is always handled by a seasoned professional.
Steps In IMG

Appraisal vs. Insurance Adjusters: What’s the Difference?

One of the biggest questions we get—and a common source of confusion—is the difference between an appraiser and an insurance adjuster. Each plays a unique role, but knowing when to rely on an appraisal can make all the difference in ensuring a fair outcome.

Appraisers
What They Do

Provide an impartial evaluation of disputed claims to resolve disagreements fairly.

Key Differences

Appraisers are independent and work to find a resolution acceptable to both parties.

Key Differences

When there’s a disagreement over the cost or scope of damages.

vs

Insurance Adjusters
What They Do

Evaluate property damage to determine the insurance company’s initial settlement offer.

Key Differences

 Adjusters represent the insurer’s interests and focus on policy interpretation.

Key Differences

During the initial claims process to assess damage and provide a starting point for payouts.

Key Takeaway

Appraisers provide independent evaluations; adjusters represent the insurance company.

Each has a distinct role in the claims process!

Contact Us
FAQ-Squares

Roof Appraisal FAQs

Appraisal can be a complex process, and it’s natural to have questions about how it works and what to expect. Below, we’ve answered some of the most common questions to help clarify the process and how ClaimRef can support you.
Who pays for the appraisal process?
Accordion Icon
Each party typically pays for their own appraiser, while the cost of the umpire is split between the policyholder and the insurance company. This ensures that the roof appraisal process is handled fairly and with shared responsibility.
How do I know if I need an appraisal or another type of dispute resolution?
Accordion Icon
An appraisal is best when the disagreement is about the value or scope of damages, not policy coverage. For issues involving insurance claims on roofs, appraisals can clarify costs and resolve disputes efficiently.
Can an appraisal decision be challenged or overturned?
Accordion Icon
Appraisal decisions are binding in most cases, but they can sometimes be contested in court under specific circumstances. These include disputes during the insurance roof appraisal process, such as fraud or procedural errors.
Do both parties have to agree to the appraisal process?
Accordion Icon
Yes, both the policyholder and the insurance company must agree to initiate the roof claims appraisal process. It is a collaborative method designed to resolve disputes without litigation.
What happens if the insurance company delays selecting an appraiser?
Accordion Icon
If one party delays, the other can request that the process move forward through written communication. For roof claims or similar cases, policies often include timelines to avoid indefinite delays.
Is the appraisal process different for commercial and residential properties?
Accordion Icon
The process is largely the same for both, but appraisers may consider different factors depending on the property type. Roof appraisals for commercial properties often involve more complex evaluations due to size and structural variations.
What qualifications should an appraiser have?
Accordion Icon
An appraiser should be impartial, experienced, and knowledgeable about property damage and repair costs. For roof claims, having a background in construction or engineering ensures accuracy in assessments.
How is the umpire chosen if the appraisers don’t agree?
Accordion Icon
Both appraisers work together to select an unbiased umpire acceptable to both parties. For insurance claims on roofs, the umpire plays a crucial role in providing a final, impartial resolution.
Does invoking the appraisal process affect my claim timeline?
Accordion Icon
The appraisal process may extend the timeline but is designed to reach a resolution faster than litigation. In roof appraisal cases, it helps avoid prolonged back-and-forth with the insurance company.
What should I expect during the appraisal process from start to finish?
Accordion Icon
The process begins with selecting appraisers, followed by inspections and evaluations of the property. For roof claims, this includes detailed assessments to determine the final value of the damage and repair costs.
FAQ-Squares
Questions-AP

Still Got Questions?

Appraisal is a complicated and often challenging process, even for experienced roofing professionals. 

That’s why we’re here to help. If you have more questions or need guidance, don’t hesitate to reach out. 

Contact us today, and let’s work together to find the right solution for your claim and make the process as smooth as possible.